diff etc/NEWS.10.md @ 33365:fb44a9db1bc6

Replace `xint_value` and related functions with stricter versions (bug #65538) The conversion function `xint_value`, `xbool_value`, and `xidx_type_value` were being used to convert input arguments to integers, booleans, or index values respectively, and to provide a meaningful error message if the conversion failed. The problem, as described in bug #65538, is that this allows user code like `all (true (3), 2.718)` to be silently converted to `all (true (3), 2)` instead of giving an error that the dimension needs to be an integer. The same happens with `cell (e, pi)`, which silently creates a 2x3 cell array. In both cases, this permissive conversion is a Matlab incompatibility. This patch provides an analogue of `xint_value` called `yint_value` that uses a stricter conversion to integer, and also does the same for `bool` and `idx_type` conversions. With this patch, passing non-integer sizes now gives an error, and passing non-boolean values to boolean arguments now give a warning. * libinterp/octave-value/ov.h: Define new functions `strict_int_value` and `strict_bool_value` and declare new function `strict_idx_type_value`. Declare corresponding new wrapper functions `yint_value`, `ybool_value`, and `yidx_type_value`. * libinterp/octave-value/ov.cc: Define `strict_idx_type_value`. Define `yint_value`, `ybool_value`, and `yidx_type_value` using the existing XVALUE_EXTRACTOR macro. * Replace the corresponding function calls in: __eigs__.cc, besselj.cc, bitfcns.cc, data.cc, file-io.cc, interpreter.cc, jsondecode.cc, load-path.cc, oct-stream.cc, ov-cell.cc, psi.cc, pt-eval.cc, sparse.cc, strfns.cc, syscalls.cc, time.cc, utils.cc, variables.cc, __glpk__.cc, __ode15__.cc, pt-eval.cc * NEWS.10.md: Add note about the Matlab compatibility of this patch. Incidentally, the new conversion functions allow a FIXME note inside `fcntl` to be addressed and removed.
author Arun Giridhar <arungiridhar@gmail.com>
date Mon, 08 Apr 2024 21:43:05 -0400
parents 3f3d7dde7f61
children 2a0cdc52220b
line wrap: on
line diff
--- a/etc/NEWS.10.md	Mon Apr 08 20:27:33 2024 -0400
+++ b/etc/NEWS.10.md	Mon Apr 08 21:43:05 2024 -0400
@@ -58,6 +58,12 @@
 - `cross` now produces row vector outputs when the inputs are a mix of row
 and column vectors. (bug #61295)
 
+- Octave functions whose Matlab equivalents give errors when passed non-integer
+values as sizes or dimensions now also give similar errors.
+E.g., `cell (e, pi)` now gives an error in Octave about requiring integer
+sizes for the cell array, matching Matlab behavior.
+Previously, Octave's conversion from non-integers to integers was more lenient.
+
 ### Alphabetical list of new functions added in Octave 10
 
 * `clim`